share

Is this dress blue and black or white and gold?

Taylor Swift, Mindy Kaling, Lady Gaga and the ELLE team weigh in on the colour phenomenon as we dig into why the world is divided on the matter

By Andrea Tim | Published: 27 Feb 2015

That Tumblr dress
Photo: Tumblr; Roman

A certain bodycon lace-detail dress has shot to Internet stardom after it started appearing everywhere on social media as netizens hotly debated its colours. Some insist that it is black and blue while others claim they see white and gold.

The dress is in fact a dark blue and black (yes, the rest of you are wrong), pictured above and sold here on fashion retail website Roman. Caitlin McNeill, the person who posted the photo on Tumblr in the first place also confirmed it.

At this point, dress-wearer Taylor Swift is probably a little worried about the priorities of the human race (because really, we're losing it), but has made it clear which side of the fence she is on.

Meanwhile, Mindy Kaling has been very passionate about defending the "objective truth" about the dress – "It's a blue and black dress! Are you f**king kidding me" – and she posted this after a long argument on Twitter...

Lady Gaga, being Lady Gaga, had a unique answer.

Anna Kendrick is already giving us ominous warnings.

Emmy Rossum is taking this more seriously than she (or we) should.

Would it comfort you to know that even Kim Kardashian and Kanye West can't see eye to eye about this?

Colours aside, Lucy Hale has made up her mind about one thing...

As for the rest of us...

Andrea Wong, Editor-in-Chief: "White and beige. That is definitely not gold."

Kate Guest, Editor, elle.my: "White and gold. Because physics."

Vanessa Palencia, Sub-editor: "White and gold. I don't see any black."

Shahrezzan Ezani, Fashion Editor: "I saw white and gold this morning, and then it became blue and black. But now I think it's blue and grey."

Jamie Khoo, Acting Associate Editor, elle.my: "Blue and gold." (What?)

Andrea Tim, Writer, elle.my: "Blue and black. It's just the lighting, you guys!"

Tengku Zai, Beauty Editor: "White and gold. Why are we perpetuating the vicious cycle of this stupid dress?"

Noor Amylia Hilda, Writer: "Hmm..."

Shufri Elfi Mifli, Graphic Designer: "I saw white and gold first, but it's blue and black now."

Verinia Khoo, Editorial Assisant, elle.my: "White and gold. Wait... blue and gold?"

Florence Song, Fashion Assistant: "The thumbnail looked white and gold, but in full size? Blue and black."

Amber Kwan, Sales Manager: "I think I'm going crazy. It's white and gold. Like, super gold."

It didn't take us long to decide, despite the difference in colour-perception here at ELLE towers, that this has something to do with the way our brains are wired to register colours. Buzzfeed spoke to Dr. Cedar Riener from Randolph-Macon College, who explained the perplexing illusion.

"We are always making decisions about the quantity of light that comes into our retina," Cedar said. "The individual differences tend not to receive as much attention from perceptual researchers, since we focus on how eyes work in general."

That explains the varying opinions about the colour of the dress.

Rockefeller University cognitive neuroscientist John Borghi also told Buzzfeed that what we experience and expect influence what we see afterwards.

"For example, what you looked at just before you looked at the dress could influence the way your brain perceived it," John said. "It could also be that you've seen dresses (or fabric) with the same texture or shape before, which could also affect your perception."

If that's not enough for those who are still curious, let the people at Wired drive you further up the wall with a more complex explanation (with some colour testing involved).


Most Popular

Advertisement

MORE, MORE, MORE

Top stories 20Jan17

Top stories 20Jan17

Also, Rain marries Kim Tae Hee, Lindsay Lohan may have converted to Islam and Uniqlo's collection with Inès de la Fressange is almost here

Top stories 13Jan17

Top stories 13Jan17

Also, Nora Danish raps, Selena Gomez kisses The Weeknd and Damien Chazelle's 'La La Land' nabs seven Golden Globes awards

SG Art Week 2017

SG Art Week 2017

Ahead of Art Stage Singapore 2017, we previewed exhibits at Sullivan+Strumpf Gallery and Pearl Lam Galleries

Emma's singing

Emma's singing

Great timing! The new 'Beauty and the Beast' teaser will help us forget about that creepy Belle doll

ELLE Instagram
Top stories 6Jan2017

Top stories 6Jan2017

Plus, Fattah Amin and Ed Sheeran release new music, Janet Jackson gives birth, and Clinique collaborates with Crayola

Advertisement
Not just a zombie

Not just a zombie

"Hawa symbolises how racial discrimination, the virus, gets in the way of true unity in our nation," director Tan Ce Ding says

NYE 2017 playlist

NYE 2017 playlist

We asked a few of our friends and colleagues to tell us what they're listening to ring in the new year

ELLE Instagram