share

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory's new cover attracts criticism

The new book cover for the Roald Dahl classic uses a cropped version of an image from a fashion shoot

By Andrea Tim | Published: 12 Aug 2014

New Charlie cover
Photo: Penguin Books

Cult classic Charlie and the Chocolate Factory's cover has gotten an "adult" facelift and already, thousands of fans and critics have voiced their disapproval.

The cover, which was cropped from a 2008 fashion shoot entitled Mommie Dearest, received tremendous backlash from fans and critics, who thought that the cover of the doll-like girl was unsettling.

Penguin released the new cover to celebrate 50 years since Roald Dahl's book was published, announcing on Facebook "This new image for Charlie and the Chocolate Factory looks at the children at the centre of the story, and highlights the way Roald Dahl's writing manages to embrace both the light and the dark aspects of life, ready for Charlie's debut amongst the adult titles in the Penguin Modern Classics series."

Oh, it's dark, alright. Criticism was hurled at how even though the intention was for the book to appeal to adults (who are believed to have a good sense of the dark realities of life), the result was a slightly creepy, misleading image that we feel does not represent the frankly more innocent story of young Charlie Bucket.

Chocolat author Joanne Harris also tweeted "I'm not sure why adults need a different cover anyway, but who was it who decided that "adult" meant "inappropriately sexualised"?

We ourselves fail to understand what it is about this cover that would actually "appeal" to adults, so we'll stick to the colourful, kiddy cover version, thanks.

Love it or hate it, the Penguin Modern Classics edition of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory hits shelves September 4.


Most Popular

Advertisement

MORE, MORE, MORE

Top stories 20Jan17

Top stories 20Jan17

Also, Rain marries Kim Tae Hee, Lindsay Lohan may have converted to Islam and Uniqlo's collection with Inès de la Fressange is almost here

Top stories 13Jan17

Top stories 13Jan17

Also, Nora Danish raps, Selena Gomez kisses The Weeknd and Damien Chazelle's 'La La Land' nabs seven Golden Globes awards

SG Art Week 2017

SG Art Week 2017

Ahead of Art Stage Singapore 2017, we previewed exhibits at Sullivan+Strumpf Gallery and Pearl Lam Galleries

Emma's singing

Emma's singing

Great timing! The new 'Beauty and the Beast' teaser will help us forget about that creepy Belle doll

ELLE Instagram
Top stories 6Jan2017

Top stories 6Jan2017

Plus, Fattah Amin and Ed Sheeran release new music, Janet Jackson gives birth, and Clinique collaborates with Crayola

Advertisement
Not just a zombie

Not just a zombie

"Hawa symbolises how racial discrimination, the virus, gets in the way of true unity in our nation," director Tan Ce Ding says

NYE 2017 playlist

NYE 2017 playlist

We asked a few of our friends and colleagues to tell us what they're listening to ring in the new year

ELLE Instagram